Free & Confidential Consultation / Call Us At 415-906-3423
practice areas

3 common criticisms of shaken baby syndrome

News outlets love to sensationalize stories of child abuse and other scandals befalling the otherwise seemingly perfect lives of suspects. The contrast between the appearance of a loving home and the gruesome details of a crime are a winning combination to garner views. One piece of evidence commonly cited in cases involving child abuse, though, is particularly controversial.

Shaken baby syndrome is a form of brain injury that results — as the name suggests — from violently shaking an infant. It is a diagnosis that often accompanies child abuse charges leveraged against parents or caretakers. According to Fox News, however, many critics are emerging to question the diagnosis.

Other medical issues may cause symptoms

The greatest issue with the use of shaken baby syndrome as evidence of abuse is the fact that many other factors can create symptoms similar to those indicating SBS. If SBS were proof of abuse, the cause of its symptoms would only be shaking an infant, but this is simply not the case. Trauma at birth or prior brain injuries can also produce effects that mirror those of SBS.

There is often a lack of additional evidence

One of the most striking characteristics of SBS cases is the shock of the abuse allegations. There may be no prior history of abuse in the household or physical evidence indicating the use of force. Even in the absence of additional evidence, however, the prosecution may present the symptoms of SBS as sufficient proof that violent abuse took place against an infant.

Jury may overreact to purported child abuse

People have a natural inclination to protect those who are vulnerable, and when presented with a child who possibly suffered harmed, juries and courts may be eager to place blame prematurely. As a result, the prosecution may invoke SBS as justification for a conviction even when there is little to no evidence that violence took place.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Start By Meeting With A Lawyer Tell Us About Your Charges

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Contact Information

Law Offices of Hanlon & Rief
1663 Mission St.
Suite 200
San Francisco, California 94103

Phone: 415-906-3423
Fax: 415-865-0376
Map & Directions

Payment Plans Available
  • Visa Card
  • Master Cards
  • American Express
  • Discover
back to top